New Mexico and Texas Employment Attorney · No Fee Unless We Win · (915) 875-0003
Home / Retaliation / Do I Have a Case?
A Straight Answer

Do I have a retaliation case?

This page is written to help you answer that yourself, in about two minutes, before you call anyone. It is honest about what is not a case, because knowing that early is worth more than a hopeful conversation that goes nowhere.

Start Here

First, the hard part.

If you are reading this, you were almost certainly treated badly. That is usually why people go looking. And there is no doubt that a great deal of what employers do to people is unfair, humiliating, and wrong.

But employment law is not built on fairness. New Mexico and Texas are both at-will states. An employer can fire you for a bad reason, a petty reason, a mistaken reason, or no reason at all — and most of the time, that is entirely legal. There is no law against a boss who is arbitrary, cold, or simply does not like you.

So the question is not how badly were you treated. It is whether one of the exceptions applies to you. Retaliation is the most common exception, and it is what the rest of this page is about.

The One Question

Was there a "before"?

Every retaliation case has one. Before the firing, before the write-up, before the hours got cut — the person did something. They reported something, asked for something, filed something, or refused something. Then they were punished.

That is the whole shape of it:

I did something the law protects → my employer found out → something bad happened to me soon afterward → the reason they gave does not hold up.

If you can fill in all four of those, you should call. If you cannot fill in the first one — if there is no "before," and the firing simply came out of nowhere — then however unfair it was, it is very unlikely to be a retaliation case.

The Checklist

What real cases have in common.

These are drawn from the patterns that recur across this office's closed files. The more of them you recognize, the stronger your footing.

1. You spoke up, asked, or refused — first.

You reported discrimination — being treated worse because of your race, sex, age, disability, religion, national origin, or, in New Mexico, your sexual orientation, gender identity, pregnancy, or military status. You reported sexual harassment. You asked for a medical accommodation or leave. You filed a workers' compensation claim. You reported something illegal, unsafe, or fraudulent. You gave a statement in someone else's investigation. You refused to do something you believed was against the law. One of those has to be true. It is the thing that separates a claim from a grievance.

Note what is not on that list: "I was harassed." Harassment on its own is not protected activity and not a claim. It counts only when the harassment was because of one of those characteristics, or when it was sexual. See below.

2. You can say who you told, and roughly when.

A named supervisor. The HR department. A hotline. A government agency. A police officer. The date does not have to be exact, but "I complained to someone at some point" is a much weaker position than "I emailed HR on a Tuesday in March." If you used the company's own complaint form or email system, that is better still — the employer's own paperwork becomes the proof.

3. It happened fast.

Hours, days, or a few weeks. Roughly a third of the cases in this office involved an adverse action within two weeks of the protected act; about two-thirds within three months. Some were the same day. If the punishment arrived quickly, that speed is itself evidence. A longer gap does not end a case — New Mexico's Supreme Court has declined to adopt any fixed cutoff — but it does mean the rest of the proof has to carry more weight.

4. The reason they gave does not hold up.

It is vague — "not a good fit," "a different direction," "it's just not working out." Or they gave no reason at all. Or the reason changed later. Or they said the position was eliminated and then filled it. Or they cited a policy that turns out not to exist in the handbook. Or they said you did something your own supervisor had told you to do.

5. Your record was clean until you spoke up.

This is the most common single fact in the files here. Years with no write-ups. Good reviews, raises, bonuses, an award. And then, suddenly, a first-ever warning or a performance plan — after the complaint, never before it. The write-up that appears only after you spoke up is one of the most valuable things a caller can have.

6. Someone else did the same thing and nothing happened to them.

A coworker who was late, or made the same mistake, or broke the same rule — and is still working there. Often the difference between you and them is that you complained.

7. They broke their own rules on you.

Skipped their progressive discipline steps. Never followed their own complaint-investigation procedure. Ignored a seniority rule. Evaluated you against the wrong job description.

8. Somebody said the quiet part out loud.

A sentence you still remember, said by someone with authority, that gave the real reason away. Sentences like that carry more weight in a file than almost anything else.

9. The company investigated, found you were right — and moved against you anyway.

It happens more than you would think. The employer substantiates the complaint, disciplines or trains the person you reported, and then gets rid of the person who reported it.

One Word, Carefully

"Harassment" is not a claim.

This is the most common misunderstanding there is, and it sends more people down a dead end than anything else on this page.

There is no law against harassment by itself. A supervisor who yells, belittles, sets you up to fail, spreads rumors, or simply makes your working life miserable is not breaking any law in New Mexico or Texas by doing it. The New Mexico Human Rights Act does not use the word "harassment" anywhere. What it makes unlawful is an unlawful discriminatory practice, and what it protects is opposing one. The Texas Labor Code uses almost identical language — it protects an employee who opposes a discriminatory practice.

Harassment becomes unlawful in two situations:

So the question is never how badly were you harassed. It is why. If you cannot connect what was done to you to one of those characteristics, or to conduct that was sexual, then reporting it was not protected activity — and being fired afterward, however unjust it feels, is very unlikely to be a retaliation case.

Being Straight With You

What is usually not a case.

None of the following are, by themselves, illegal — no matter how unfair they were:

All of that can be completely true and still be lawful in both New Mexico and Texas. The difference is not how badly you were treated. The difference is whether you spoke up first, whether you can say when, and whether they moved against you afterward.

If none of the nine items above describe your situation, this office will very likely not be able to help — and will tell you so quickly rather than let you wait.

Things People Get Wrong

Five assumptions that cost people cases.

"I hadn't been there long enough." Length of service is irrelevant to a retaliation claim. Matters in this office have been brought for people with a few weeks on the job and for people with thirty years.

"It wasn't me who complained — I just backed up a coworker." Participating in someone else's complaint is protected exactly as if it were your own. The Supreme Court has held this covers an employee who simply answered questions when the employer came asking.

"I never complained about anything — I just asked for time off for surgery." Asking for a medical accommodation or leave is itself a protected act. You do not need to have complained about anything at all.

"I was wrong about what I reported, so I'm not protected." Generally you are, as long as you had a reasonable basis for what you believed. The protection attaches to reporting in good faith, not to being right.

"They're too big to fight" — or, just as often, "they're too small." Neither is true. Large employers with real HR departments actually generate more provable retaliation cases, because the complaint channel creates the dated, documented record the case runs on. And if you worked through a staffing agency or a PEO and have no idea who technically employed you, that is not a barrier either.

If You Think It Fits

What to have ready.

You do not need to know which law applies. That is this office's job. What is worth pulling together before you call:

If it is safe and lawful for you to do so, keep copies of your complaint, your reviews, and the termination paperwork. Do not take anything you are not authorized to access. If you are unsure what you may keep, ask before you do anything.

Don't Wait

Every one of these claims has a clock on it.

Some are much shorter than people expect. The sooner you call, the more options are still open.